An ecosystem in danger: the Mexican museums

Foto_Archivo Cuartoscuro_retraso-pago-trabajadores-cultura-condiciones-laborales.jpeg
Photo: Archivo Cuartoscuro. Source: Animal Politico

10 December 2020

It is difficult still to piece together a clear picture of the full impact of the Covid-19 crisis on museums worldwide and the lasting damage that is being done. Within this moment of crises facing many museums internationally the situation of the public museums in Mexico stands out as being of particular concern. The Mexican public museums do not have financial autonomy from the state and their viability is entirely dependent upon state support. This position may on the surface be one that many museum professionals would envy as an alternative to the neoliberal model that has become dominant within international museums, however in Mexico it might now become a recipe for disaster.

Mexico has an internationally recognised public museum system, especially the network of national and university museums in Mexico City. The national museums within the purview of the Federal Secretariat of Culture comprise two categories; the art institutions that are part of INBAL, the National Institute of Fine Arts and Literature and INAH, the National Institute of Anthropology and History.

There are a number of alarms being raised that signal the significant crisis facing museums in Mexico. Firstly there has been widespread public protest from within Mexico’s cultural scene [reference to article, click] and in addition museum workers from across the country have staged a strike [reference to articles, click (1), click (2), click (3)]. Also, from our perspective, we get the impression that museum professionals working within state museums are doing so within a framework of censorship with an official letter of June 12th spelling out that public servants should be guided by the ethical principles of management as led by the President of the Republic (“ …since December 11, on several occasions to the heads of this sector that our actions must unwaveringly be guided by the ethical principles of the administration led by the President of the Republic… “).

Since mid-2018, Mexico has been ruled by a dynamic populist coalition under President Lopez Obrador, his National Regeneration Movement teaming up with the left-wing Labor Party and a right-wing Christian-conservative party. Upon first glance, this government may seem culturally inclined, even setting up an ambitious cultural development plan for the vast Chapultepec Forest city park that already houses a number of important museums with more in development, including a Kunsthalle led by internationally renowned artist Gabriel Orozco.

A more detailed look at the situation however reveals a more complex and worrying picture. The current government has started to dismantle the revered public institutions that have been developed over many generations. May 2019 saw the first in a series of draconian austerity measures with cuts of up to 50% in funding for activities such as exhibitions programmes. The situation deteriorated further following a Presidential decree on April 23rd 2020 that capped 75% of the operating budgets of public museums funded by INBAL. This critical situation is made even worse by the fact that these reduced budgets only become effective when museums are formally notified of their assigned budgets. For decades this happened in March, in 2019 it took place in June and it has not happened at all in 2020.

Furthermore, regional museums that are funded by federal cultural support programmes under S268 have suffered budget cuts of 76.53% since 2018. Their financial position has been further destabilised by the Covid-19 pandemic and the subsequent drastic reduction in opportunities for self-generated income. In addition it should also be noted that a large majority of museum workers are hired on a temporary basis under the category Capítulo 3000 of the 33901 budget line. This status denies them appropriate labour rights and healthcare, fundamental rights at any time but of critical importance during this pandemic.

Despite these devastating cuts in funding to museums a budget of $175 million has been assigned to the new Chapultepec Forest development which has been identified as a national priority. The cultural sector in Mexico has raised concerns about the appropriateness of these ambitious development plans at this time. [reference to Frente Pro Museos letter dated May 22, 2020, click]. CIMAM recognises that while ambition for new cultural institutions should be welcomed this has to be balanced against a responsibility by the state to support the wider cultural eco-system that provides the ground for new ambitions. CIMAM is concerned that the current government in Mexico has lost sight of the duty of care it has for the cultural institutions that it inherited whilst it plans for ambitious new developments.

CIMAM considers that safeguarding the culture and heritage of its people is a prime responsibility of government. Institutions that safe-guard our culture take many years to develop but can be destroyed by a few critical decisions. CIMAM is deeply concerned that the actions of the current government in Mexico will lead to the destruction of these important cultural institutions. The Chairperson of CIMAM has written to the Secretary of Culture to express CIMAM’s grave concern and to ask the Mexican government to take immediate action to rectify these devastating cuts [letter can be seen here, click]. This letter was copied to the Director of INBAL and the Secretary of International Affairs in recognition of the damage to Mexico’s international standing that CIMAM fears will result from this damaging cultural policy.

10 December 2020

The Museum Watch Committee of the CIMAM Board: Bart De Baere (Chair), Calin Dan, Sarah Glennie, Malgorzata Ludwisiak, Victoria Noorthoorn, Eugene Tan.

CIMAM – International Committee for Museums and Collections of Modern Art – is an Affiliated Organisation of ICOM – International Council of Museums.

→ Read the reply from the Mexican Secretary of Culture to CIMAM. 15 December 2020

→ Read the letter sent to the Mexican Secretary of Culture. 10 December 2020

→ Read this statement in Spanish: Un ecosistema en peligro: los museos Mexicanos.

→ Read the letter sent to the Mexican Secretary of Culture in Spanish.

In the press

→ Proceso, by Judith Amador, 18 April 2021, Museos en crisis, desde antes de la pandemia.

→ The Art Newspaper, by Elizabeth Mistry, 11 March 2021, Mexico's culture crisis: pandemic leads to budget cuts that leave many workers unpaid while vanity projects receive millions.

→ Art Guide Russia, 14 December 2020, International Committee of Museums and Collections of Contemporary Art raised concerns about the cultural sector in Mexico.

→ Excelsior, 14 December 2020, Los Museos en Extinción.

→ Artnet News, by Brian Boucher, 11 December 2020, An International Cultural Organization Says Mexico’s Museum Leaders Are Afraid to Speak the Truth About Their Dire Financial Straits.

→ Suracapulco, 11 December 2020, Recortes a museos arriesgan la supervivencia a los recintos, señala ONG mundial.

→ El Debate, 11 December 2020, Museos de México: Alarma ante la grave crisis que enfrentan.

→ El Universal, 11 December 2020, Preocupan museos públicos a instituciones internacionales.

→ Zócalo, by Agencia Reforma, December 2020, Alertan a Secretaría de Cultura sobre crisis de museos.

→ El Universal, 11 December 2020, Preocupan museos públicos a instituciones internacionales.

→ Art Critique, by Katherine Keener, 11 December 2020, Art World Roundup: CIMAM on dire position of Mexico museums.

→ FabWorldToday, by Shubhangi Chavan, 11 December 2020, To revise its cultural institutions, Mexico is in international burden.

El Universal, 10 December 2020, Museos mexicanos: ecosistema en peligro.

→ Artishock, 10 December 2020, Museos mexicanos. Un ecosistema en peligro.

→ Crónica, 10 December 2020,Los museos públicos mexicanos, un ecosistema en peligro: CIMAM.
→ El Porvenir, 10 December 2020, Museos de México. Alarma ante la grave crisis que enfrentan.

→ Hiperallergic, by Valentina Di Liscia , 10 December 2020,Mexico Is Under International Pressure to Reform Its Cultural Institutions.

→ Arteinformado, 10 December 2020, A vista de pájaro: delicada situación del galerismo español y museístico mexicano, premios internacionales a museos y artistas y más.

→ En24, 10 December 2020, Museums of Mexico. Alarm before the serious crisis they face.

→ Reforma, 10 December 2020, Alertan sobre crisis de museos mexicanos.

→ Votoblanco, 10 December 2020, Museos de México en crisis.

→ El Norte, by Grupo Reforma, 10 December 2020, Alertan sobre crisis de museos mexicanos.

→ El Siglo del Torreón, 10 December 2020, Denuncian alarmante crisis por recortes en museos de México.